Arthur is a hopeless romantic and crazy about Broadway musicals. He believes that great things can meet you at every step and fateful love will sweep you away. When he runs into Ben during summer vacation in New York, he feels like the universe is giving him a sign. This wasn't a coincidence, there was something special about this meeting… Ben doubts the universe was on his side. He just broke up with his boyfriend and is really in no mood for a new relationship. But even he can't get Arthur out of his head... What if they never meet again in the city of eight million inhabitants? What if they do… but their first date turns out to be a total disaster? What if life really isn't a Broadway musical? And what if it is?